Employees aren’t dishonest.
They’re protective.
Most organizations run surveys. They host town halls. They ask the right-sounding questions. And the feedback comes back polite. Reasonable. Safe.
Everyone is “mostly satisfied.” Collaboration is “generally good.” Leadership is “approachable.”
Yet attrition rises. Engagement stalls. Employer brand messages don’t land.
Something’s off.
The protective instinct
Employees don’t just work at a company. They represent it.
Even when things aren’t working, there’s an unspoken instinct to avoid sounding disloyal, to protect managers they like as people, to not create problems that could come back to them.
So when you ask internally—”How are things going?”—what you often get is the edited version.
Not lies. Just omissions.
Internal surveys are efficient. Scalable. Measurable. They’re also predictable.
Employees know that responses are tracked, even when anonymous. That patterns can be traced back to teams. That strong opinions rarely lead to positive outcomes.
So the language becomes careful. “Sometimes challenging.” “Opportunities for improvement.” “Could be better aligned.”
This is corporate fluency, not emotional truth.
And employer branding built on this kind of data always sounds fine. Never distinctive. Never magnetic.
The moment the real story emerges
Something interesting happens about 30 minutes into an externally facilitated focus group.
The first half sounds familiar. “We’re collaborative.” “People are supportive.” “Leadership cares.”
Then someone pauses and says: “We say we’re collaborative, but…”
That “but” is where the truth lives.
Because external facilitators aren’t part of internal politics. They don’t evaluate performance. They don’t carry organizational history.
The room relaxes. Stories replace statements. And once one person speaks honestly, others follow.
In one focus group, a team proudly described their culture as “fast-moving and entrepreneurial.”
Thirty minutes later, the same group said: “Honestly, it’s exhausting. You’re always on. If you slow down, you feel invisible.”
Both statements were true. Only one would ever show up in a survey.
This is why employer brands often feel disconnected from lived experience. They’re built on what employees can say, not what they want to say.
What you discover when you listen this way
The most revealing insights rarely come from ratings. They come from stories.
When employees stop answering as “staff” and start answering as humans, patterns emerge. Pride mixed with frustration. Loyalty alongside burnout. Meaning paired with ambiguity.
These tensions aren’t weaknesses. They’re the raw material of an authentic employer brand.
At Brandemix, this is where we start. External research creates space for employees to move from performance to perspective. The conversation shifts. Employees stop trying to give the “right” answer and start talking about their actual experience.
What emerges is rarely shocking, but it’s clarifying.
The culture is stronger than leadership realizes, but less consistent. Growth opportunities exist, but only for those who already know how to access them. Flexibility is valued, but unevenly experienced.
When this truth is acknowledged, employer branding shifts. From aspirational to credible. From polished to human. From generic to specific.
And that’s what people actually trust.
Truth isn’t a risk
Employer brands don’t fail because they’re honest. They fail because they’re incomplete.
When organizations are brave enough to hear the full story—including the uncomfortable parts—they stop guessing who they are as an employer.
They start recognizing themselves.
And that recognition is what future employees respond to.
Because people aren’t looking for perfect workplaces. They’re looking for real ones.
What emerges from external research isn’t a list of complaints or a polished success story. It’s a clearer, more grounded understanding of what the organization truly offers.
And when employer branding is built from that place, it stops feeling aspirational or scripted.
It becomes recognizable. Believable. Human.
That’s when messaging resonates—not because it promises everything, but because it reflects reality.
External research reveals the truth your internal surveys miss. At Brandemix, we facilitate these conversations for organizations across industries—creating the neutral space where real insights emerge.
Ready to hear what your employees aren’t saying?
Get in Touch
FAQs
-
Why don’t employees speak honestly in internal surveys?
Because honesty feels risky. Even anonymous surveys carry perceived consequences, so employees often soften or filter their responses.
-
What is external employee research?
External employee research involves third-party facilitators conducting interviews or focus groups, creating a neutral space where employees feel safe sharing real experiences.
-
How do focus groups reveal insights surveys miss?
Focus groups allow for conversation, storytelling, and follow-up questions. Insight often emerges gradually, especially once trust builds in the room.
-
Why is honesty important for employer branding?
Employer branding built on partial truth feels generic. Honest insights help organisations articulate a brand that matches real employee experience, which builds trust with candidates.
-
Can negative feedback harm employer brand?
Not when handled well. Acknowledging complexity makes an employer brand more credible and relatable, not weaker.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Jody Ordioni is the author of “The Talent Brand.” In her role as Founder and Chief Brand Officer of Brandemix, she leads the firm in creating brand-aligned talent communications that connect employees to cultures, companies, and business goals. She engages with HR professionals and corporate teams on how to build and promote talent brands, and implement best-practice talent acquisition and engagement strategies across all media and platforms. She has been named a "recruitment thought leader to follow" and her mission is to integrate marketing, human resources, internal communications, and social media to foster a seamless brand experience through the employee lifecycle.
